Sunday, March 30, 2008

Film Adaptation and Blade Runner


We're now turning our attention to the film Blade Runner, a loose adaptation of PKD's Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep?. I want us to contemplate what the film does, that the novel does not and vice versa.

The film scholar Dudley Andrew suggests that where literature elaborates a world out of a story, cinema carves a story out of a world. This distinction is fascinating to consider (and the kind of conundrum that PKD might have appreciated). How doe novels and films tell different kinds of stories? Lets consider for a moment the artistic, ideological, and economic issues that arise when works are adapted. Which novels are you familiar with that have been adapted into film? What choices did the director make? Why do you think these choices were made? What were the results?

According to Andrew, there are three primary methods of film adaptation: borrowing, intersecting, and transforming. If we apply these terms to science fiction film, Star Wars can be viewed as a film that "borrows" its basic narrative from the legend of King Arthur, relying on the mythic power of an original source. A sci-film like Solaris "intersects" with an original text, that is "the uniqueness of the original text is preserved to such an extent that it is intentionally left unassimilated in adaptation." The adaptation of H.G. Wells' The Time Machine on the other hand, "transforms" an original source into the medium of film, attempting to remain faithful to the literary experience.

Why is Blade Runner considered such an important sci-fi film? Perhaps its biggest achievement is the creation of a future Los Angeles (versus San Francisco in novel) the that is imaginative and at the same time believable. One scholar, Brooks Landon, suggests thinking about the film as an adaptation that "frames" its antecedent, serving as "a lens for better understanding its source and as a mirror for better studying ourselves." Consider the city of the future. What would your visual design look like?

Viewing Strategies

Consider the literary, dramatic, and cinematic aspects of film.

Literary elements include characterization, theme, and symbolism.
Dramatic elements include mise-en
scene (costume, props, acting)
Cinematic elements include camera angle/movement, light, color, sound, editing, special effects


Playing Detective with Film Allusions


Each of you will receive a textual or pictorial "clue" to the film's meaning. You will conduct research on your clue. What is it? You must complete independent online research. As detectives, you must then write a short report on your clue, prior to viewing the film. After viewing the film you will amend your report providing observations and possible connections to the film. You will then present your findings to the class and lead a discussion on your clue. Scenes can be replayed at this time. Please post your report on your blog and include images or text when appropriate.

DADES 13-22

Please complete a blog entry for Chapters 13-22. Also complete free writing on the topic below. Use textual evidence from the novel and your notes, including those blow. Be prepared to discuss.

Humanity in Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep?
Discuss the problems of human identity Philip K. Dick addresses in the novel. What does Dick reveal about human beings as opposed to machines> How does he complicate the simple division between what is natural and what is unnatural?

The Problem of Human Identity

What characteristics make us distinctively human?

Androids and specials are persecuted “races” and DADES might be said to be an allegory of racial conflict, which includes urbanization and “white flight.”

Irony that a machine is used to test for humanness (Voight-Kampff test), an empathy box (machine) is needed to experience “fusion” with others, and a machine (Penfield mood organ) is used to regulate mood.

Recycling of Frankenstein myth—androids are human-created monsters on the loose

Is Deckard a human or an android and why?

Human (Natural) / Non-Human (Unnatural)


Birth/sexual reproduction / Artificially created
Empathy / Lack of empathy
Impulse/instinct / Programming
Love of animals / Animals as objects
Awareness of past / Lack of past; focus on present
Collective awareness / Self-preservation
Sisyphus mentality / Resignation to defeat
Ability to die / Shut down, retired
Human / Beyond human

Sunday, March 9, 2008

DADES: Chapter 12


Edvard Munch's "The Scream"







How might this painting relate to androids? To humans?


"The painting showed a hairless, oppressed creature with a head like an inverted pear, its hands clapped in horror to its ears, its mouth open in a vast, soundless scream. Twisted ripples of the creature's torment, echoes of its cry, flooded out into the air surrounding it; the man or woman, whichever it was, had become contained by its own howl. It had covered its ears against its own sound. The creature stood on a bridge and no one else was present; the creature screamed in isolation. Cut off by--or despite--its outcry" (114).

Phil Resch says "I think...that this is how an andy must feel" (114).


Luba Luft, the opera singer, is absorbed by a picture of "a young girl, hands clasped together, seated on the edge of a bed, an expression of bewildered wonder and new, groping awe imprinted on the face" (115).

Edvard Munch's "Puberty"



Why is Luba Luft fascinated by this painting?

DADES: Chapter 10-11

These are the "twilight zone" chapters. It's here that PKD begins to play with his reader. What is real and how do we know? Who should we believe? Is Rick Deckard an android? What evidence do we have that he might be? What evidence do we have that he is indeed human? Is the fact that there a question what's important? What is PKD trying to suggest about the human condition?

Are androids trying to "retire" the humans, just as the humans are trying to "retire" the androids? If so, aren't they both "killers." Remember Mercerism claims that "you should kill only the killers" (pg. 27)Huh?

Traits of an android: cold, cerebral, detached, lacking in empathy, cannot fuse with Mercer, don't care what happens to other androids, synthetic memory systems,

Tuesday, March 4, 2008

DADES: Chapter 9

Read and complete a journal posting for Chapter 9 for Friday. Post by 9pm Thursday evening and give feedback to two of your classmates.

DADES: Chapter 8

Write another entry for Chapter 8.

Consider Deckard's feelings at the end of the novel. What are we learning about our protagonist? How does he compare to J.R. Isidore? For your journal posting, consider using SOAP. Identify paragraphs, sentences, phrases, or words that Surprise, Offend, Amuse, or Puzzle you.

I still want to see video clips from everyone. Quiz tomorrow 3/4.